Welcome to State Library Victoria's Tablo community – we're here to support emerging Victorian writers and provide a space for readers and authors to connect.

Do you think Harry Potter is worth it ?

Is Harry Potter worth reading ? What are your thoughts?

  • Created
32f6b3d73068523be4369690b1311823.png?d=https%3a%2f%2ftablo.io%2fassets%2fuser avatar default thumb

HP is a cracking read. The story is multi layered and the wizarding world JK Rowling created is consistent and believable. Plus, HP is an icon of our times - many pop culture references have been derived from its sayings and characters. I think it is also interesting as a cultural phenomenon. I envy any new time HP explorer the thrill of encountering this world for the first time!

32f6b3d73068523be4369690b1311823.png?d=https%3a%2f%2ftablo.io%2fassets%2fuser avatar default thumb

Absolutely! If you are moved to do a fanfiction I think that there is plenty to further explore using the characters and settings of HP. I look forward to reading your work :)

Reply arrow green
7f91382380f30da5266a08dd5d5b9901.png?d=https%3a%2f%2ftablo.io%2fassets%2fuser avatar default thumb

I'm an older person and kind of missed Harry Potter's entry onto the world literary stage. I was studying and doing other things.

As a former children's librarian, I knew that eventually I'd revisit him and I did but just couldn't get interested. The films made it all a little harder too.

Yet I loved Le Guin's 'Earthsea Quartet', Pullman's 'His Dark Materials', Tolkien's 'Hobbit' etc, and I deeply respect JK Rowling.

I guess it's just preference. Some of the celebrity hype around Harry Potter put me off too.

I love JK Rowland's adult mysteries. Of course they are completely different.

Perhaps someone can persuade me to try again with Harry!

8c4dee5b85162d97e5f66c52c4056681.png?d=https%3a%2f%2ftablo.io%2fassets%2fuser avatar default thumb

The Harry Potter Books are 100 times better than the movies if only because of the extraordinary details; and engaging ones imagination because of it.

Reply arrow green
Thumb 0289f83e 2cea 473c 8501 6d8453baf893

Brilliant original and intelligent plot and very well written. CS Lewis was the author that ignited my love of fantasy when I was a child and JK Rowling did the same for my daughter. Reading the Harry Potter series to her was a brilliant experience!

Reply arrow green
Thumb 49f758c7 1f99 4f4d b945 e09ca1c14031

The idea is good, it really captures the imagination. But the writing is lacking. So if you can put up with average narrative, mostly boring characters and bland dialogue, I'd say give it a try and decide if its worth it yourself.

Reply arrow green
Log in to comment Join Tablo